Wednesday, October 28, 2009

Red Bend v. Google Chrome -- No Damages?


Matt Asay over at CNet had an interesting idea in terms of the ability of patent plaintiff's ability to collect damages over Google's use of open source software. He opined that under the proposed patent reform act, plaintiffs would be unable to collect damages for patent infringement because, under the proposed legislation, damages would be calculated based on the difference between using the infringing technology and using the next best non-infringing substitute. He theorized that this might be the reason that Google was supporting patent reform.

In my view, however, this same result would occur even under current law. Currently, damages are calculated (or are supposed to be) based on a "hypothetical negotiation" between the patentholder and the infringer. Damages are supposed to be awarded based on what the parties would have licensed the patent for in that negotiation. If, in the Red Bend situation, Google could have replaced the Red Bend compression algorithm with another open source algorithm at no cost (other than the cost of changing the algorithm), it would have paid very little to Red bend to license the patented algorithm -- in fact, in that situation, the patent would be virtually worthless. The damages awarded for the infringement of a worthless patent which is easily worked around are very low -- even under current law.

Thus, if Google does its damages analysis right, it should be able to get out of this case cheaply.

And, if open source software provides lots of low cost or free substitutes, the same should apply across the board.

14 comments:

Anonymous said...

Hmmmm....reminds me of SCO.

Alan Harrison said...

Interestingly, consideration of possible non-infringing substitutes for allegedly infringing software opens up a recursion on the infringement-determination module of the litigation process.

Anonymous said...

Yes if the truth be known, in some moments I can say that I acquiesce in with you, but you may be making allowance for other options.
to the article there is quiet a question as you did in the downgrade delivery of this request www.google.com/ie?as_q=daemon tools pro 4.10.218.0 - 32bit64bit ?
I noticed the phrase you have in the offing not used. Or you functioning the dark methods of helping of the resource. I take a week and do necheg

Viagra Online said...

Excellent post, and I think Chrome is a great tool, specially if you're an student who loves the Internet, because is very easy to use and anyone can understand the applications. This web browser can't be better and we won't ignore the importance about it because the Windows version of Chrome includes Gears, which adds features for web developers. j23j

forgery said...

I enjoyed reading it. I'm supposed to be somewhere else in a minute but I stuck to reading the story. I like the quality of your blog :D

Viagra without prescription said...

yeah, you are right, this symbol have many similitudes to the ancient, but the good thing is that in certain way, thanks to Chrome, all will remember Red Bend.

Martina said...

Goodness, there's so much effective info above!

Anonymous said...

buy clomid price [url=https://flavors.me/clomidhere#6e7b]order clomid[/url] [url=https://flavors.me/stratteranorx#0u0x]order strattera[/url] atarax without prescription USA mop cheap clomid pharmacy hbf clomid no rx zithromax online kamagra pills cheap kamagra no rx hrp

Anonymous said...

buy clomid price [url=https://flavors.me/clomidhere#6e7b]order clomid[/url] [url=https://flavors.me/stratteranorx#0u0x]order strattera[/url] atarax without prescription USA mop cheap clomid pharmacy hbf clomid no rx zithromax online kamagra pills cheap kamagra no rx hrp

Anonymous said...

Кабельная продукция - один из важных продуктов, используемых для полнофункциональной работы электрооборудования. Многообразие моделей и марок кабеля на сайте ООО "Спецкомплект" предоставляют широкий выбор для оптового и розничного заказчика.
Компания предлагает ассортимент качественных товаров, таких как К1153, К1154, К1155, КМ, силовой кабель ВВГ, ВБбШВ, СИП, АСБ, ENSTO арматура СИП, оптический кабель ОКГ, ОКБ, ОКЛ, ОКК.
Сборка щитового оборудования высокого качества по доступной цене, смотрите обзор на сайте компании.
Specomplect: [url=http://specomplect.ru]лотки К1163[/url]

Anonymous said...

Возведение жилых и промышленных многоуровневых объектов влечет за собой привлечение особой строительной техники, оборудованной для осуществления конкретных задач. Выполнение строительных работ происходит по этапам, в связи, с чем, задействовать строительную технику тоже доводится по шагам, в зависимости от поставленных задач.
Но закупка таковой особой техники влечет огромные затраты. Поскольку стоит она дорого, компания "Сапрос" рекомендует услуги аренды строительной техники. Наш автопарк укомплектован всем важным для строительства автотранспортом. Моментальный заказ спецтехники можно создать через интернет, заполнив заявку онлайн на сайте фирмы. В Самаре мы пользуемя популярностью именно за высококачесвенное и оперативное сопровождение клиентов, предоставляя такую услугу, как аренда бары. Наши специалисты при необходимости в полном объеме проконсультируют Вас о более подходящем под запросы автотранспорте, что позволит сэкономить и время и деньги.
SAPros.Ru - [url=http://sapros.ru]аренда экскаватора погрузчика в самаре[/url]

Muneer Hussian said...

case study solution
case study solution
case study solution
case study solution

case study solution
case study solution
case study solution
case study solution

case study solution
case study solution
case study solution
case study solution

case study solution
case study solution
case study solution
case study solution

case study solution
case study solution
case study solution
case study solution

case study solution
case study solution
case study solution
case study solution

case study solution
case study solution
case study solution
case study solution

case study solution
case study solution
case study solution
case study solution

Adams Scott said...

A lot of people in our industry haven't had very diverse experiences. So they don't have enough dots to connect, and they end up with very linear solutions without a broad perspective on the problem.
Advertising agencies in Karachi | Advertising agencies in Pakistan

obat Herbal said...

Glad to visit your site. An awesome blog. Nice Information It's really very informative that I wanted ever, thanks for this. Jual Peninggi Badan Alami Bali Ratih Obat Jerawat Obat Asam Urat Alami Kapsul Mengkudu Obat Pelangsing Badan HerbalMadu Hitam Pahit Masker Wajah Alami